MSC Cruises vs. Royal Caribbean: A Real Cruiser’s Perspective

When travelers weigh MSC Cruises against Royal Caribbean, the choice often comes down to style, value, and priorities. A recent Reddit post from a cruiser who’s sailed both lines provides a refreshingly honest comparison that sheds light on the little details many reviews gloss over.

According to this frequent cruiser, Royal Caribbean stands out for its sheer scale and volume of things to do—especially on its Oasis and Quantum-class ships. Think surf simulators, ice skating rinks, Broadway-style shows, and more complimentary entertainment than you could ever get to in a week. If you want your vacation packed with non-stop activities and high energy, Royal tends to deliver. But that comes with a price tag to match.

MSC, on the other hand, often surprises people with its pricing. The Redditor noted that MSC offers significantly more value, particularly when you compare similar cabin categories or itineraries. While Royal’s suites and upgraded experiences can quickly skyrocket in cost, MSC’s Yacht Club—essentially a ship-within-a-ship experience—is priced far more accessibly and delivers perks like a private restaurant, lounge, pool, butler service, and priority everything. The tradeoff? A slightly more relaxed pace and fewer included activities, which is actually a plus for those who like a quieter vacation.

Dining was another big differentiator. While Royal Caribbean offers a wide range of complimentary dining, the food was described as “okay” by the original poster, who felt MSC’s quality—especially in specialty restaurants—was stronger overall. That said, Royal’s variety wins for people who want choices without paying extra. MSC’s dining style is a little more European in flavor and presentation, and for some cruisers, that feels more upscale and intentional.

MSC’s Ocean Cay or Royal’s CocoCay?

Private island experiences are a good example of the broader difference in vibe. Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay is action-packed, with water parks, ziplines, and optional cabanas—it’s a theme park at sea. MSC’s Ocean Cay Marine Reserve is its opposite: peaceful, natural, and designed for relaxation. There’s music at night, glowing beach paths, and a slow pace that makes you feel like you’re on your own little island retreat. Both are wonderful—just in completely different ways.

There are some trade-offs worth noting. Royal Caribbean generally gets higher marks for bar service, the speed and attentiveness of crew interactions, and the availability of entertainment throughout the day. MSC’s staff and service are improving, but they sometimes lag a little behind in consistency depending on the sailing or region. It’s worth noting that in the U.S. market, MSC is still growing and adjusting, which can create a few hiccups that seasoned Royal cruisers might notice.

In the end, what works best really depends on what kind of vacation you’re looking for. But we love that real cruisers are out there having these honest conversations, and we’re always happy to help interpret them for your personal travel goals.

Why Book Your Cruise with Lask Travel Advisors?

We don’t just plan vacations—we curate experiences. As CLIA-certified cruise specialists and seasoned travelers, we help clients find the perfect itinerary, cabin, and excursions to match their style. Want the best private snorkeling guide in Grand Cayman? Looking for a quiet stateroom away from the noise? We’ve done it, and we’ll tailor it for you.

Our clients appreciate the insider knowledge, personalized attention, and stress-free planning we bring to every booking. Plus, we’re always happy to chat cruises over coffee if you’re near Folsom.

Ready to Set Sail?

Let’s turn your dream cruise into reality. Whether you’re cruising for the first time or looking to upgrade your next adventure, we’ll help you navigate every detail—from ship selection to shore excursions.

📧 Contact us today to start planning your getaway. Your next adventure begins here—with Lask Travel Advisors

To explore a variety of cruise options and find the best fit for your next adventure, be sure to visit our Cruise search and booking page. From family-friendly holidays to luxurious getaways, your ideal cruise awaits!